That sustainability is a clearly defined idea with broad agreement. Without that clarity it is easy to state that Exxon's actions are more sustainable than Tesla's.
it is pushing the world deeper and deeper in the climate change problem because a few people want to make more money
Unless the rationale for the criteria are clearly explained it is difficult to understand how such a decision to keep an oil company on an ESG list but drop an EV car maker.
Depends on the context. The truth according to S&P or the "real" truth?