Difference between revisions of "Verdict:AffHfj3hjHaf6hf0ch0h/1"
From cm2.liecourt.com
(Edited with WSForm) |
(Edited with WSForm) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Verdict | {{Verdict | ||
| + | |Role=Juror | ||
| + | |Workflow=Workflow/187 | ||
|Case ID=AffHfj3hjHaf6hf0ch0h | |Case ID=AffHfj3hjHaf6hf0ch0h | ||
| − | |||
|User=User:Justin | |User=User:Justin | ||
| − | | | + | |Truth=no |
| − | | | + | |Truth percentage=75 |
| + | |Truth text=The researchers assume that all life forms are carbon-based and subject to the natural selection process, which relies on continuous competition. | ||
| + | |Whole truth=no | ||
| + | |Whole truth percentage=75 | ||
| + | |Whole truth text=There is an unstated bias that assumes that all life will be similar in development and behavior to ours. | ||
| + | |Nothing But the truth=no | ||
| + | |Nothing But the truth percentage=75 | ||
| + | |Nothing But the truth text=The notion of "life" is too narrowly defined. "Life" forms could exist that are utterly beyond our comprehension, and may easily avoid the Great Filter. | ||
| + | |Deceit=That all life follows "natural" laws similar or identical to what we understand. | ||
| + | |Deceit percentage=75 | ||
| + | |Deceit text=- | ||
| + | |Deceit intended=no | ||
| + | |Deceit intended percentage=75 | ||
| + | |Deceit intended text=Many scientists exhibit twin biases of which they are blissfully unaware: 1) that we understand (or can understand) the fundamental nature of reality; 2) that "life" and intelligence only develops in ways that fit current science. | ||
| + | |Motivation=The motivation is unintentional. Scientists believe that they are advancing knowledge. | ||
| + | |Motivation percentage=75 | ||
| + | |Motivation text=- | ||
| + | |Social acceptability=Unacceptable | ||
| + | |Social acceptability percentage=50 | ||
| + | |Social acceptability text=At this point in our development as a species. these faulty assumptions are mostly benign. | ||
| + | |Label=This claim does not take into account unexamined underlying assumptions. | ||
| + | |Label percentage=100 | ||
}} | }} | ||
Latest revision as of 17:14, 16 November 2022
Not permitted
